Winning DMV hearings for CVC 23136: “Zero Tolerance” Winning Minor DUI cases

September 23, 2016

Vehicle Code 23136

Vehicle Code 23136 …it is unlawful for a person under the age of 21 years who has a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.01 percent or greater, as measured by a preliminary alcohol screening test or other chemical test, to drive a vehicle…

Description of  CVC 23136

A California Vehicle Code section 23136 says it is a crime for anyone below the age of twenty-one to drive with a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of at 0.01% or above.  This law is recognized as California’s “zero tolerance” law for underage DUI.  If you are accused of CVC 23136, you can have your driver’s license suspended for one year by the California DMV.

California’s zero-tolerance law for minor DUI is prosecuted even if the alcohol not only alcoholic drinks.  Even medicines consisting of alcohol can make you liable for a VC 23136 violation. Under Vehicle Code 23136, BAC can be determined by a preliminary alcohol screening (PAS) device.  A PAS test is a roadside test given using a portable breathalyzer.  It takes a sample of your breath to measure the quantity of alcohol in your blood. The PAS devices can be very inaccurate.  So, if you are accused of this “minor” DUI in Los Angeles please contact a attorney from our office right away to help you fight and win your DUI case and to help you keep your license after a DUI arrest.

License Suspension

Violation of Vehicle Code 23136 is not a crime, but a civil offense. The penalty for breaking this “zero tolerance” minor DUI law is a suspension or cancellation of your driver’s license by the DMV.  This is known as an administrative “per se” (also known as an “APS”) suspension.  If you do not have a license yet and you get arrested for a “zerro tollerance” DUI in Los Angeles, you can be punished by the DMV who will delay your ability to get a driver’s license by one year.

If you are cited for violation of CVC 23136, the police officer will confiscate your driver’s license, if you have one, and mail it to the DMV.  Instead of your driver’s license, the arresting officer will be issued a temporary driver’s license.  The temporary driver’s license issued by the police officer is only good for thirty days.  When the thirty-day period ends, your DUI related driver’s license suspension or DUI related driver’s license cancellation will go into effect.  To stop that, you or a Los Angeles DUI attorney must contact the DMV within ten days of the stop.  When you or your Los Angeles DUI defense attorney does, he will ask for a hearing with the DMV to dispute the suspension.  You can also ask for a DMV hearing if the police officer accuses you of a refusal to take a alcohol screaning test or other chemical test after a DUI arrest in Los Angeles.  This is why it is extremely important to contact a DUI defense attorney right away. Doing so will help you defend your driver’s license and possibly avoid a driver’s license suspension.

The Hearing

The “zero-tolerance” DUI hearing by law has to take place by telephone or in-person.  Ever since COVID, the DMV was ordered not to have in-person hearing and moved all hearings to “by telephone”.  The hearing is between you and the DMV.  The DMV in this situation is accusing you of the “minor DUI” and at the same time is deciding the facts and applies the law to this facts.  Because of that, those hearing are hard to win and you will need the help of Los Angles DUI Attorney to win at this hearing.  At the hearing, you don’t have to produce any evidence – because the DMV has the burden to proof that you (1) drove the vehicle in violation of a traffic law – which is usually based on a reasonable suspicion standard for the police officer to pull you over; (2) were lawfully detained – which can be based on such little evidence as the police officer smelling alcohol; and (3) that preliminary alcohol screening device test showed your blood alcohol level above .01 %.

At the hearing, the evidence is usually presented through a DS-367 DMV form which the citing officer signs under the penalty of perjury.   You have the right to present evidence – however, unlike all the other alcohol tests, CVC 23136 does not have to comply with Title 17. This is so because a level of .01 BAC can be reported as a negative (Title 17 Section 1220.4).  If the courts will allow Title 17 to be used for CVC 23136 enforcements – .01 BAC results would create a legal impossibility.  Attorney General in 1989 also explicitly stated that title 17 does not apply to PAS devices (72 Ops.Cal.Atty.Gen. 226, 230).  Using PAS devices in Minor DUI cases is grounded in zero-tolerance law: that is, presence of alcohol in any amount will result in driver’s license suspension, unlike adult DUI cases, where a specific level is used as evidence at trial.

However, the police officer’s testimony that PAS showed the presence of alcohol is not enough to take your driver’s license away.  (Coniglio v. DMV 39 Cal.App.4th 671).  The DMV must establish Adam’s foundation for PAS admisibilty.  This requirement comes from Coniglio v. DMV and from Santos v. DMV 5 Cal.App.4th 549 and Davenport v. DMV 6 Cal.App.4th 140

In Coniglio, the driver won DMV hearing because the reliability of the PAS test was not established:  This was so because:

(1) the officer was only trained for 2 hours on the breathalyzer;

(2) the officer did not know how the device worked scientifically;

(3) there was no testimony on how the PAS device was maintained;

(4) there was no testimony showing that the PAS test was properly administered.

Refusal of Breath Test

A refusal to submit to a chemical test can be explicit—namely, you clearly inform the officer you are refusing to submit to the chemical test. But, the refusal can also be implicit—for instance, you stay quiet when asked if you consent to the breath test. In addition, the officer can deem an unsuccessful test attempt as a refusal when you failed to complete a test after you consented to do it. For example, the officer might decide that you are not breathing hard enough into the breathalyzer and this is the reason he is not getting any reading.

If the DMV proves that you refuse to take the breath test, in California you can have your license suspended for one year. You could face also a two-year license suspension if the DMV proves that you refused the chemical test within 10 years of another refusal, or a reckless-driving or DUI conviction. If the DMV proves that you refused a chemical test for the third time within ten years or refused for the first time but have had over one reckless-driving or DUI conviction within a decade, the penalty increases to three-year license revocation. The refusal can not be proven unless you were validly informed of the consequences of the refusal.   As part of the case, the police officer has to testify that he read an admonition, informing you of the consequences of the refusal to submit to a chemical test. In addition to the DMV prosecution, the police can also submit a criminal case to the prosecutor. If the prosecutor files a criminal case, you will have to defend in criminal court or in juvenile court and if found guilty you can be punished by the court with additional punishment. The fine for refusal to take tests, under Vehicle Code 14905 is $125 but the fines are often run into thousands because of additional statutory penalty enhancements.

Driving Record, Points and Collateral Consequences

If you are a minor, the penalties for a traffic infraction can be harsh. A violation of CVC 23136, a zero-tolerance alcohol-related driving has no point, but as discussed above, a minor will receive a one-year license suspension if the DMV is able to prove the driving over the .01 limit.

An underage .01 DUI will stay on your record, and you might be required to report it on college or job applications. For that reason, it is extremely important to choose the right attorney to defend your case. Some employers or school will take a very hard position against you if you fail to report any violation of the law including a .01 or other DUI violations or conviction The consequences of such violation can result in the initiation of expulsion proceedings which can be used to terminate your admission to the school. You can also be fired from our job for many violations of law including .01 underage DUI. Disclosing a conviction might not necessarily prevent you from being admitted to school or being hired on a job. In addition, some colleges will not approve scholarships after a DUI conviction. It is important to contact an attorney after an arrest to discuss your options.

Lastly, some jobs require a special license or certification that you might not be eligible for if you have even a minor DUI on your record. No matter what happens, having to report of a DUI on an application can be awkward at the best and would affect you for the remainder of your life.

What is a Hardship Restriction?

Under Vehicle Code 13353.8 when an order suspending your driving privilege is issued because of a violation of Vehicle Code 23136 (a), the department might lift restrictions on an individual’s driving privilege based on a presentation of a “critical need to drive.” This is relevant if, within a decade of the present violation of Vehicle Code 23136, the driver has no other significant record such as have previous APS action or conviction and has not been suspended or canceled for refusing to take a PAS or other chemical test.

“Critical need to drive” indicates that the conditions that are needed to be presented to issue a junior permit under California Vehicle Code 12513. Kinds of restrictions permitted might be:

  • To and from school or work
  • For family illness
  • For family enterprise and/or business
  • Do not levy the restriction before the thirty-first day after the effective date of the suspension

An application for Critical Need Restriction, DS 694, must be finished and presented to the Driver Safety Actions Unit in headquarters. If it is approved, you must pay a reissue fee of one-hundred dollars and submit a California Insurance Proof Certificate, SR-22. Once it is received, restriction and comment specifying the suspension may be lifted and you can get a license to the driver under the critical need application.

Los Angeles DUI Attorney

(818) 921 7744  Contact a DUI attorney right away to get free advice.

waste of timepoornot badgoodexcellent (5 rating, 1 votes)

Comments are closed.